Skip to content
← Our work

Automotive manufacturing

Deciding vehicle content and pricing with choice models and Monte Carlo optimization

Statistical choice models, Monte Carlo simulation and optimization that decide which features each trim carries as standard, optional or not offered, and at what prices.

2 min read Partner experience, prior role

Client

Global automotive manufacturer

Basis

Partner experience, prior role

The insight

“Every feature is a pricing decision. Re-pricing a vehicle line moves profit a little; re-contenting it, so buyers stop paying for features they do not value, moves it a lot.”

Exhibit

Re-contenting earns 17% more and wins share

Expected profit against market share for content-and-price plans

$400$600$800$1,000$1,200 30%40%50%60% Market share → Share 35.2%, $1,201 per buyerShare 45.7%, $1,103 per buyerShare 53%, $861 per buyerShare 55.4%, $737 per buyerShare 61%, $475 per buyer Efficient frontier Profit-maximizing plan: 35.2% share, $1,201 per buyer Optimized content and price Engineering-led baseline: 31% share, $1,023 per buyer Engineering-led baseline

Illustrative, from Field Note 12: a synthetic three-trim, nine-feature line with mixed-logit buyers and a competitor. Each frontier point is a content-and-price plan found by optimization; the engineering-led baseline sits inside it.

Which features, on which trims, at what price

Long before a model year launches, an automaker must decide its content: which customer-facing features each trim carries as standard, which are offered as options, which are not offered at all, and at what prices. Engineering, sourcing and manufacturing then build around those choices for years.

A combinatorial pricing problem nobody can enumerate

Even a modest line of three trims and nine features has trillions of possible content plans, and buyers differ widely in what they value. A feature made standard everywhere forces some buyers to pay for something they do not want; a feature held back may send others to a competitor. Rules of thumb and cost-plus pricing cannot see those trade-offs.

Choice models, Monte Carlo and optimization together

This work, led by Adam DeJans Jr. and John Brandon Elam in earlier industry roles, combined statistics, probability, Monte Carlo simulation and optimization. Statistical choice models estimated how heterogeneous buyers trade features against price; Monte Carlo simulation carried the uncertainty in those estimates into the profit of each candidate plan; and optimization searched content assignments and prices together. The approach closely parallels the vehicle content optimization General Motors has published, which GM reports produced $4.4 billion in verified incremental profit across its programs; that figure is GM’s, not this work’s.

Plans that raise profit and customer value together

The method’s value comes from re-contenting rather than re-pricing: in the field note’s synthetic worked example, re-pricing a baseline line gains under 1%, while optimizing content and prices together gains 17% in expected profit and raises share and customer value. Financial outcomes for this work are not published.

First page of Field Note 12

Field Note 12 / 3-page PDF

Every Feature Is a Pricing Decision

The full write-up: the content decision as a combinatorial pricing problem, mixed-logit models of heterogeneous buyers, Monte Carlo over preference and parameter uncertainty, content search with inner price optimization, and a synthetic worked example.

What made the difference

01

Model what buyers value

Statistical choice models estimated how much different buyers value each feature and how they trade features against price.

02

Carry the uncertainty

Monte Carlo simulation propagated the uncertainty in those estimates into the profit of every candidate plan, so plans were compared on risk as well as expectation.

03

Optimize content and price together

Optimization searched the enormous space of feature assignments by trim, with prices set for each candidate, to find plans that raise profit and customer value together.